I too have bought a house with a koi pond. Upper pond is about 12ft. diameter, it flows down a water fall to a smaller pond. Shutting off the pump the lower pond holds water. The upper pond has lost 2 3/4 ft in two weeks. I have since removed the fish to the lower pond, drained the upper pond, Removed the plug in the drain at the bottom of the upper pond. Thus far I have not seen an obvious area the upper pond is leaking at. My next step is to pressure wash the upper pond liner. It is epdm material. I will do a closer inspection for damage or leaks. I kind of feel like I am in a fish pond fishing for something I am not sure what? I thought when I got to this point the leak would be blatant. Any thoughts would be appreciated. I'd like to put a die in it with some fancy CSI light that would show the leak area. !!!!!!!