Blue Heron Deterrent Research

Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
4,523
Reaction score
3,717
Location
Desoto, Texas (Dallas County) North Texas, Zone 8a
Showcase(s):
1
Since my pond is a fishless nature pond I do not have Blue Heron issues yet I know many of you do. Having plenty of free time I've researched the topic. I hope at least one of the following is a new idea for you. Good luck.

• DECOYS/SCARECROWS – There are many types of decoys available to help deter the Great Blue Heron. There are owls, coyotes, snakes, and crocodiles but the most popular decoy is a fake Great Blue Heron. The decoy is shaped, colored, and decorated to appear like a small 30”H GBH. The theory is that herons like to hunt alone; and this is true when it is a smaller body of water like a backyard pond. However, if a larger heron sees a smaller heron hunting pond side there is nothing that will keep the bigger bird from chasing away the smaller bird from the hunting grounds. I have seen video of a rather large Great Blue Heron beating the heck out of a decoy, and the real heron won! All things considered, even if the fake little heron decoy keeps the hungry real life heron away from your pond even just once or twice, then it is money well spent. A good thing to do also is to move the decoy heron to different areas from time to time so it is not too easy for the real GBH to figure out it is looking at a mannequin of itself. Other decoys available are owl decoys, wide eyed and freaky looking, some of them even come with sound effects and moving parts; these would be the most effective decoy, but it will also scare away other more desirable birds from your pond too! I’ve seen decoy coyotes that can help as well. Remember the idea is to have a multi level approach to keeping the heron away, and a fake snarling coyote near the pond (not necessarily next to) may save the day for you. Remember if it works even once, it is money well spent. Another great decoy to use is an artificial koi, called “de-koi”, these life size and realistic looking koi fish can be tethered in your pond to float just below water surface. When a heron is hunting your pond it will try to work as little as possible for its meal, and when it sees that big juicy koi just hovering there like easy pickins’, the heron will likely attack the de-koi which creates an alert to the real fish that can now go into hiding with the presence of a predator brought to their attention. The de-koi is a brilliant last defense for your koi, the down side is that the GBH has to be IN your pond for it to work. The Scarecrow is not a straw filled, flannel shirted, wide brimmed hat, man on a stick; no, the Scarecrow is a motion activated mechanism that points to its target and shoots a sudden and startling burst of water at or in the direction of what ever is moving around your pond, including YOU! They can be very effective the first few times which makes them a good investment. This heron deterrent also should be moved around the pond to keep any persistent predators surprised at the blast of water. This is a good deterrent to have in your arsenal of defenses. Approx. cost $45.00 – $120.00

• SHADOW/SILHOUETTE CUT OUTS – We’ve all seen the shadow cutout of the leaning cowboy, or the even more popular German Shepard cut outs that are used to keep geese away from municipal, golf course ponds, or even open fields. Well, why shouldn’t koi pond owners use them too? A cut out can go a long way in protecting your pond from predators and it does not even need to be next to the pond. Strategically place the cut out in an area of proximity to the pond that you are sure will be seen by the heron while it is scouting out your pond. This cut out should give the bird enough doubt about the area being safe to hunt that it will likely choose to move on to another hunting ground that does not have the shadowy outline of a large dog standing close by. Approx. cost $120.00

• TALK RADIO – Ok, now here is my secret method. Talk radio. A Great Blue Heron will not usually want to get to close to an area that has human activity. Try leaving an outdoor radio left on by your pond while you are away from your pond. A GBH will not get too close to any area that has human voices chatting away, so any good news station or talk radio station will work very well at keeping our big blue friend away. If you really want to terrify the bird, put on The Howard Stern show, Great Blue Herons and most local wildlife may never return! (j.k. love ya Howard!) Approx. cost $15.00

• PREDATOR CALLS – On one hand they are hilarious, and I have found it is a great way to scare not just herons but daughters too. Yes that’s right, a motion activated predator call broadcaster. Broadcasting the sound of calls from various land predators and birds of prey is a technique that has been used by wineries and other agricultural industries to keep away pesky crows and other critters that want to eat their crops. Now small models are available that can be installed close to your pond. Let the neighbors try to figure out why growling noises and screams from large birds of prey keep coming from your general direction, the GBH does not have time for that and the first call will have him high tailing it out of the vicinity of your pond! Approx. Cost $90.00+

- I use the Scarecrow and have had no fish losses. I got it at AZ Ponds two years ago for $58 on sale. The Motion Activated Scarecrow: This motion-sensored sprinkler is a great way to deter not only herons but other predators as well. The sprinkler simply hooks up to a garden hose and is triggered by motion. There is a dial on the sprinkler that adjusts the sensitivity. When a heron/predator approaches sensor, it shoots a 3-second burst of water up to 180 degrees.

- The only thing that I can say works is the heron chaser. http://www.pondfiltration.com/heron.html

- http://www.birdcontrolpro.com/control_heron.htm
 

addy1

water gardener / gold fish and shubunkins
Moderator
Joined
Jun 23, 2010
Messages
44,404
Reaction score
29,178
Location
Frederick, Maryland
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
6b
Country
United States
My alligator heads worked until I put the island in. Then the bird had a place to land in the middle of the pond. Floating island is gone now!
 

j.w

I Love my Goldies
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
33,061
Reaction score
20,334
Location
Arlington, Washington
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
USDA 8a
Country
United States
I have had a radio on talk radio on my front covered porch right by the pond loud enough for the heron to hear for a couple yrs now set to come on at dawn and off at dusk. Works like a charm so far! Also have the gator head and a short wire fence around the pond w/ dangly windchimes, whirly things etc. Have not seen the heron in a long time...........knock on wood!
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2010
Messages
3,214
Reaction score
1,296
Location
Phoenix AZ
I read once I believe that Fish & Game believed Heron decoys attracted Herons. There are a lot of videos on YouTube showing live Herons fishing next to decoys.
 
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,275
Reaction score
2,818
Location
Plymouth
Hardiness Zone
7a
Country
United Kingdom
I agree with you waterbug I've heard tale of that before at a koi farm in Lostwithial down in Corwall Jon the owner was telling me of the trouble they caused to the koi he was raising., They simply moved a little further down the pond from the decoy to do thier own fishing.
Jons take on heron decoys not worth the money you pay for them .
They also got used to having water jets firing off near them , the cat decoy he put out was useless , I think the heron a very intelegent bird .
The one thing I've heard that does work is if they are foiled the very first attempt with say a tightly meshed nylon net with Bungy strap ties like the 6mm hexagonal one we have.
Then they wont bother with the pond again but you have to have a pond that can take this type of net i;e free standing ,
The mesh has to be this sized hole as anything larger then they can do serious damage spearing the fish but not actually being able to catch it.
Thus leaving you with the task of trying to repair the damage done by the herons sharp beak .

rgrds

Dave
 
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,275
Reaction score
2,818
Location
Plymouth
Hardiness Zone
7a
Country
United Kingdom
It is a fact that any wild creature when it discovers that its not treatened by something like the Heron Decoy water Jets etc rapidly loose their fear of of those meathods used to scare it .
In reality you'd be better off enploying a pet cat to do the scaring off of the heron ,our cats themselves weve found dont bother with our koi basically because the pond is part of their territory .
One Millionaire in Cornwall went one better than any decoy by giving the Heron both barrels of a shotgun, was arrested for it and fined £2,500 uk. When asked by a a BBC Southwest news reporter (was it worth the fine) he replied yes of course it was the koi he was snacking on in that pond were all worth above £10,000

rgrds

Dave
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads


Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
30,879
Messages
509,652
Members
13,098
Latest member
Snowy

Latest Threads

Top