Fry have ich! How do I save adults?

M

MariaTeresa

About 1.5 weeks ago we added 3 new fish to the pond to replace the ones that got eaten. Two shubunkins and a sarasa. I thought the sarasa might have had a little white dot on it before I put it in the pond, but it was on its white body, so hard to tell. Obviously I should not have put it in the pond. (I don't have, and can't have, a set up for quarantine...so I do realize and accept the risk I take.) I kept an eye on that fish and it is my most active fish. Spawning has been going on between my comet and my common consistently for weeks. The poor common has lost a LOT of scales on both of her sides from being shoved into the rocks. She has been more sedate than usual, but I still think that is due to exhaustion from all the spawning...or complications from losing the scales. She's also been hiding a lot since the heron attack. I have seven "big" fish....the comet and common that are spawning, the sarasa, the two shubunkins and two 'mutts' born last fall who are about 5" and starting to turn orange. Beyond that, as of last night, I have a LOT of fry, from 1.5" down to the newly hatched. The water is 75F. Testing the water is not a possibility for me, but I'm guessing the quality isn't the greatest because the pump had been broken for a few weeks (new one in now) and the severe thunderstorm a week or two ago washed tons of mud and runoff into the pond. I have been adding a product that reduces ammonia in case that was an issue during the time the pump was broken.

Yesterday I had was looking very carefully at the fry and noticed that a lot of them had their gills swollen open with lots of white stuff hanging out. I'd say between 2/3 and 3/4 of the bigger fry were like that. I also noticed that 2/3 to 3/4 of those fry had white spots. Little tiny white ich spots. They were acting normal yesterdat, but this morning I haven't seen any of them and there is a large reduction in the amount of fry. So I'm guessing they died last night. Some remaining fry also have ich.

None of my "big" fish have any white spots (that I can see), no clamped fins, no isolating (except for my spawning female when she's not spawning she's sometimes hiding), all are active. I don't feed, but I've seen all of them munching around the pond. In other words, if it weren't for the ichy fry I wouldn't be concerned about them.

So here's my question: what do I do? The "Fancy Goldfish" book says when fry get ich there's not much you can do about it. For adults it recommends adding salt. It also mentions formalin and copper. According to the book both salt and copper would harm the plants and formalin would harm the fish. It also says ich is usually fatal, but that sometimes a healthy fish can eradicate the parasites from its body and sometimes fish can live with ich.

I'm assuming that the ich is replicating a lot from all the fry and so that even if the adults aren't infected now, they are stuck in the contaminated water and it will eventually wear them down. Plus, if the adults are munching on the fry, would ingesting an ichy fry give them ich?

Has anyone had ich in a pond with plants that can't be removed and been able to eradicate it? How?
 
M

MariaTeresa

All of the ich treatments I've found seem to be for aquariums, or will harm plants/ invertebrates/tadpoles. Does anyone know of an ich treatment for ponds that is safe for tadpoles/snails/plants/fish?

Edit: Will Microbe-lift Ich Out work? Is that safe for snails, tadpoles, and plants?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,275
Reaction score
2,817
Location
Plymouth
Hardiness Zone
7a
Country
United Kingdom
Basically You have a choice Maria terasa tadpoles or fish which are more important to you ?
Stark choice I know sorry :cry:
Dave
 
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,275
Reaction score
2,817
Location
Plymouth
Hardiness Zone
7a
Country
United Kingdom
The only other thing you could do is get down and dirty and catch all the adults in the pond then transfering them to a Qr tank for treatment but you still have the pond to contend with and treat any remaining fry in your pond

Dave
 
Last edited:
M

MariaTeresa

:cry: I only have one tadpole and he just grew back legs! He's so close to hopping out of the pond, but too hard to catch. I contacted Microbe-lift and they claim Ich-Out is safe for tadpoles and snails, but the info on the bottle has the warning DoDad mentioned. I really don't want to chance it.

I've purchased Kordon's Ick Attack instead. It's apparently "organic" "all natural", etc. but safe for plants, fish, snails,and scaleless fish (which I'm hoping will sort of include tadpoles), etc. The reviews on amazon are mostly positive, and since none of the adult fish have spots yet I'm hoping this might work. I'm okay with losing the remaining fry. This stuff is supposed to be safe for them but we'll see. By the time this treatment is done the tadpole should be a froggy and I can try the Ich Out if the pond is still ichy. A LOT of animals drink from the pond though, including our dog, and I'm worried that they'd all get sick or worse.
 
M

MariaTeresa

I finally was able to test my water!
Ammonia 0
Nitrite 0
Phosphate 1.0
pH between 7 and 7.5

Unfortunately, the Kordon's Ich Attack is not going to work. Once I received the bottle I saw that it would take 500mL once a day for five weeks to treat ich. That would cost $245! So I dumped the bottle in and hoped it would do some good. We don't have the money to treat the pond, so we may lose the fish.

Incidentally, what should the phosphate reading be? 0? Is the 1.0 reading a problem?
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Similar Threads

One week old fry 16
Fry with 2 tails 10
Should I keep the fish fry in the pond? 3
Koi-Met' fry 7
Fry 2
Fish fry myths? 4
This is what 100,000 Koi fry that a Female koi fish lay will make you awe! 8
Raising fry 2

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
30,781
Messages
508,561
Members
13,042
Latest member
lucaryan

Latest Threads

Top