I thought this was a shbunkin who was going to have babies, but I just read shubunkin have eggs, this one always lay fry. have had babies every spring and fall for about 5 years. Our weather turned warm,water was about 65 for about a week ( aobut the time she started getting fat) very early then cooled off and even snowed.water dropped to 45 is she waiting for the water to warm up again or is she sick? she is so fat her scales have seperated! have about 20 fish bought at various times but now not sure which are koi, shbunkin, commets or gold fish! some are over 10 years some from babies (some born black and change colors) last year.