do goldfish change color with age?

j.w

I Love my Goldies
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
33,090
Reaction score
20,350
Location
Arlington, Washington
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
USDA 8a
Country
United States
I just looked this up and found it interesting:

You can read the whole article here but I just posted the short version below:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koi

The carp is a large group of fish originally found in Central Europe and Asia. Various carp species were originally domesticated in East Asia, where they were used as food fish. The ability of carp to survive and adapt to many climates and water conditions allowed the domesticated species to be propagated to many new locations including Japan. Natural color mutations of these carp would have occurred across all populations. Carp were first bred for color mutations in China more than a thousand years ago, where selective breeding of the Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio) led to the development of the goldfish.

Carp are known as koi in Japan. Of the various domesticated carp species, the common carp (Cyprinus carpio) is one of the more commonly used in aquaculture. The common carp was aquacultured as a food fish as at least as far back as the 5th century in China. Common carp were first bred for color in Japan in the 1820s, initially in the town of Ojiya in the Niigata prefecture on the north eastern coast of Honshu island. By the 20th century, a number of color patterns had been established, most notably the red-and-white Kohaku. The outside world was not aware of the development of color variations in koi until 1914, when the Niigata koi were exhibited in the annual exposition in Tokyo. At that point, interest in koi exploded throughout Japan. The hobby of keeping koi eventually spread worldwide. Koi are now commonly sold in most pet stores, with higher-quality fish available from specialist dealers.

Extensive hybridization between different populations has muddled the historical zoogeography of the common carp. However, scientific consensus is that there are at least two subspecies of the common carp, one from Western Eurasia (Cyprinus carpio carpio) and another from East Asia (Cyprinus carpio haematopterus). One recent study on the mitochondrial DNA of various common carp indicate that koi are of the East Asian subspecies. However another recent study on the mitochondrial DNA of koi have found that koi are descended from multiple lineages of common carp from both Western Eurasian and East Asian varieties. This could be the result of koi being bred from a mix of East Asian and Western Eurasian carp varieties, or koi being bred exclusively from East Asian varieties and being subsequently hybridized with Western Eurasian varieties (the butterfly koi is one known product of such a cross). Which is true has not been resolved.

Differences from goldfish
Koi have prominent barbels on the lip that are not visible in goldfish.

Goldfish were developed in China more than a thousand years ago by selectively breeding Prussian carp for color mutations. By the Song Dynasty (960 – 1279), yellow, orange, white and red-and-white colorations had been developed. Goldfish (Carassius auratus) and Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio) are now considered different species. Goldfish were introduced to Japan in the 16th century and to Europe in the 17th century. Koi, on the other hand, were developed from common carp in Japan in the 1820s. Koi are domesticated common carp (Cyprinus carpio) that are culled for color, they are not a different species and will revert to the original coloration within a few generations if allowed to breed freely.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Differences from goldfish

In general, goldfish tend to be smaller than koi, and have a greater variety of body shapes, and fin and tail configurations. Koi varieties tend to have a common body shape, but have a greater variety of coloration and color patterns. They also have prominent barbels on the lip. Some goldfish varieties, such as the common goldfish, comet goldfish and shubunkin have body shapes and coloration that are similar to koi, and can be difficult to tell apart from koi when immature. Since goldfish and koi were developed from different species of carp, even though they can interbreed, their offspring are sterile.
 

addy1

water gardener / gold fish and shubunkins
Moderator
Joined
Jun 23, 2010
Messages
44,414
Reaction score
29,205
Location
Frederick, Maryland
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
6b
Country
United States
So us goldie peeps, just have cheap koi! lol
 
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Messages
673
Reaction score
122
Location
alberta canada
shakaho said:
The "feeder" goldfish at our local Petsmarts come in in beautiful condition. They go downhill rapidly because of bad water from overcrowding. Of course I quarantine all new fish, but I have never had a health problem with any of the fish I picked out of the $.13 or $.28 tanks. That is not the case with the goldfish that cost multiple dollars. Most of those look sick or at least stressed in the store. Of the seven I have bought from the expensive tanks, all of which looked perfectly healthy, two died, and two others had problems that appeared during quarantine.
wow i totally agree, petsmart has amazing feeder fish, unlike other petstores they are actually pretty big and they have really nice colors, the whites and reds always look really amazing and i noticed that when you go to the other petstores the feeder fish seem to be all orange and maybe some browns but no petsamrts goldfish...i wonder why?
Paying more for fish doesn't mean they will be disease free. Quarantine is still necessary.
yes quarantine is necassary, though i have to be honest and say that i do not quarantine my fish but i do look around carefully throughout the tank and make sure the fish all look clear eyed, healthy and alert. one time when i had my tropical tank i introduced a group of tiger barbs and all the fish in the tank had died or gotten severly sick, i lost 4 angels, and a few other expensive fish, i was really upset that day, but strangley i have never ever had ich or other fungal diseases in my tanks in the whole 10 years of fish keeping.
fishin4cars said:
AMEN! Your 100% correct. I've bought the 10/$1.00 and had all ten grow up to be beautiful fish, spent hundreds of dollars on one and it arrived sick. Money spent does not mean if the fish is healthy or not. The problem with feeder fish is from birth to the time they arrive to be sold they are in crowded conditions. In must cases somewhere along the line they usually get placed in inadequate holding tanks. Not to say they were sick when they arrived, but If you look at petsmart, Petco, and most chain pet stores for example, look and see if they use a system that filters water thru all their tanks into one filter. (All the Goldfish on one system, all the africans cichlids on one system, all the south Americans on one system etc.) This is where a big issue usually starts, the expensive fish come in, one may be sick, the Massive load of feeders come in, Lots of ammonia, and waste in the bag. the store employee dumps the load in the feeder tank. Well, you guessed it that one fish that started off sick now has all the feeders sick, the expensive fish sick and the cycle is underway. (This is the primary reason to quarantine, You the hobbyist can't know for sure if it has or has not been exposed.)
On the changing colors, I would guess that maybe 10-20% of goldfish change color in their lifetime, Shubunkins and multicolored fish are going to change the most. Black,& blue are the least stable, 95% of the time a red and white will stay red and white but the pattern may change slightly. Orange and black, 95% of the time will change during their life. usually loosing the black to some degree. The thing I must say is if it does sit back and enjoy the amazing changes, you can't stop it and many times over, the change will somehow turn out even better than you ever expected.
i deffinately agree

j.w said:
I just looked this up and found it interesting:

You can read the whole article here but I just posted the short version below:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koi

The carp is a large group of fish originally found in Central Europe and Asia. Various carp species were originally domesticated in East Asia, where they were used as food fish. The ability of carp to survive and adapt to many climates and water conditions allowed the domesticated species to be propagated to many new locations including Japan. Natural color mutations of these carp would have occurred across all populations. Carp were first bred for color mutations in China more than a thousand years ago, where selective breeding of the Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio) led to the development of the goldfish.

Carp are known as koi in Japan. Of the various domesticated carp species, the common carp (Cyprinus carpio) is one of the more commonly used in aquaculture. The common carp was aquacultured as a food fish as at least as far back as the 5th century in China. Common carp were first bred for color in Japan in the 1820s, initially in the town of Ojiya in the Niigata prefecture on the north eastern coast of Honshu island. By the 20th century, a number of color patterns had been established, most notably the red-and-white Kohaku. The outside world was not aware of the development of color variations in koi until 1914, when the Niigata koi were exhibited in the annual exposition in Tokyo. At that point, interest in koi exploded throughout Japan. The hobby of keeping koi eventually spread worldwide. Koi are now commonly sold in most pet stores, with higher-quality fish available from specialist dealers.

Extensive hybridization between different populations has muddled the historical zoogeography of the common carp. However, scientific consensus is that there are at least two subspecies of the common carp, one from Western Eurasia (Cyprinus carpio carpio) and another from East Asia (Cyprinus carpio haematopterus). One recent study on the mitochondrial DNA of various common carp indicate that koi are of the East Asian subspecies. However another recent study on the mitochondrial DNA of koi have found that koi are descended from multiple lineages of common carp from both Western Eurasian and East Asian varieties. This could be the result of koi being bred from a mix of East Asian and Western Eurasian carp varieties, or koi being bred exclusively from East Asian varieties and being subsequently hybridized with Western Eurasian varieties (the butterfly koi is one known product of such a cross). Which is true has not been resolved.

Differences from goldfish
Koi have prominent barbels on the lip that are not visible in goldfish.

Goldfish were developed in China more than a thousand years ago by selectively breeding Prussian carp for color mutations. By the Song Dynasty (960 – 1279), yellow, orange, white and red-and-white colorations had been developed. Goldfish (Carassius auratus) and Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio) are now considered different species. Goldfish were introduced to Japan in the 16th century and to Europe in the 17th century. Koi, on the other hand, were developed from common carp in Japan in the 1820s. Koi are domesticated common carp (Cyprinus carpio) that are culled for color, they are not a different species and will revert to the original coloration within a few generations if allowed to breed freely.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Differences from goldfish

In general, goldfish tend to be smaller than koi, and have a greater variety of body shapes, and fin and tail configurations. Koi varieties tend to have a common body shape, but have a greater variety of coloration and color patterns. They also have prominent barbels on the lip. Some goldfish varieties, such as the common goldfish, comet goldfish and shubunkin have body shapes and coloration that are similar to koi, and can be difficult to tell apart from koi when immature. Since goldfish and koi were developed from different species of carp, even though they can interbreed, their offspring are sterile.
nice read and very intresting, i wonder why goldfish and koi can't breed to produce fertile young?

addy1 said:
So us goldie peeps, just have cheap koi! lol
hahah addy it would appear so, we have ghetto koi but i must say that i think goldfish are just as beautiful and have many advantages over koi:bouncycig:
 
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
543
Reaction score
179
Location
Winter Springs FL
The hybrids of koi and goldfish are sterile because they have an odd number of chromosomes. Koi have 50 chromosomes, and goldfish have 100. The hybrid will have 25 chromosomes from the koi parent and 50 from the goldfish parent. 75 chromosomes cannot be divided in half into eggs and sperm, so these have various numbers of chromosomes. Fertilization results in zygotes (fertilized eggs) with extra chromosomes and/or (usually and) missing chromosomes. These zygotes can't develop and just die.
 
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Messages
673
Reaction score
122
Location
alberta canada
Wow goldfish have 100 chromosomes and koi have 50 that's amazing considering how much more complex humans are and yet we have less and that goldfish have more then koi but are like 1/4 the size or less genetics are just amazing
 

addy1

water gardener / gold fish and shubunkins
Moderator
Joined
Jun 23, 2010
Messages
44,414
Reaction score
29,205
Location
Frederick, Maryland
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
6b
Country
United States
talal101 said:
Wow goldfish have 100 chromosomes and koi have 50 that's amazing goldfish have more then koi but are like 1/4 the size


Yeah Goldfish are better than koi, more chromosomes! Goldies win! laughing
 

sissy

sissy
Joined
Jan 17, 2011
Messages
33,086
Reaction score
15,702
Location
Axton virginia
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
7A
Country
United States
my fish change colors all the time and I was guessing amount of sun the pond gets .I have orange ones that are now white ,black one is now orange and black all orange one is now black white and orange
 
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
304
Reaction score
7
Location
Ontario So. Cali
Ive bought some .10 goldfish from petsmart less then a year ago and now they are 5-8 inch with a large enough pond and plenty of food they will grow quick, I am starting to thin out the goldfish heard as i had 17 and got rid of 5 so i can have mostly Koi in my pond.
 
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Messages
673
Reaction score
122
Location
alberta canada
addy1 said:
Yeah Goldfish are better than koi, more chromosomes! Goldies win! laughing
hahah addy im not sure it works that way because it would make goldfish and koi better then people lol but have to agree that goldfish have many advantages over koi
sissy said:
my fish change colors all the time and I was guessing amount of sun the pond gets .I have orange ones that are now white ,black one is now orange and black all orange one is now black white and orange
sounds like a very pretty fish, i wonder if its possible to set up a pure breeding line of goldfish and get them to produce the same exact colored babies?
bsr8129 said:
Ive bought some .10 goldfish from petsmart less then a year ago and now they are 5-8 inch with a large enough pond and plenty of food they will grow quick, I am starting to thin out the goldfish heard as i had 17 and got rid of 5 so i can have mostly Koi in my pond.
it really is about that care you give them, but then again alot of the time it is genetics:twisted:
 
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
543
Reaction score
179
Location
Winter Springs FL
Are you ready for a little more genetics? Having more chromosomes is not a mark of superiority. I believe the most chromosomes is claimed by some kind of fern.

This is what I learned. Not only all other carp, but most other fish, have 50 chromosomes. The goldfish (wild and domestic), with 100 chromosomes, is tetraploid. Just a reminder of what that means for those whose last biology course was long ago: You, like almost all animals, are diploid. Your cells have 2 sets (di) of chromosomes (n=46). Eggs and sperm are haploid. They have one set of chromosomes (n=23). Goldfish have four (tetra) sets of chromosomes. The species originated when a diploid egg met a diploid sperm.

The result of this is that goldfish genetics is a complete mess.
 

addy1

water gardener / gold fish and shubunkins
Moderator
Joined
Jun 23, 2010
Messages
44,414
Reaction score
29,205
Location
Frederick, Maryland
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
6b
Country
United States
Well thanks for the bio lesson, lol. I have a masters in it but some of the knowledge has faded with age (umm time lol). So we that have goldies have to understand the poor little goldies need extra love and care since their genetics is such a mess!
 

j.w

I Love my Goldies
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
33,090
Reaction score
20,350
Location
Arlington, Washington
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
USDA 8a
Country
United States
I read somewhere that they (goldies) have a memory of about 3 months and then kaplooey it is gone :rolleyes: But then what do they really need to remember for that long, as they get fed each day or whatever and so the memory refill starts all over again. Hey sometimes I can't remember stuff from last week..............I mean can you remember what you had for dinner last Thursday? :bowdown:
 

j.w

I Love my Goldies
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
33,090
Reaction score
20,350
Location
Arlington, Washington
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
USDA 8a
Country
United States
Oh wait I forgot..................last Thursday was yesterday wasn't it :bowdown:
 
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Messages
673
Reaction score
122
Location
alberta canada
thanks shakaho i understand it better now, and also lol addy i think its time not age, and where do i start with you j.w, "oh wait..........last thursday was yesterday wasn't it" looool hahahah too funny
 
Joined
Mar 14, 2011
Messages
433
Reaction score
56
Location
Carolinas
hmmm...sounds like a genetic experiment, like what percentage of orange to white will you get if you breed a white goldfish with a solid orange goldfish? I took genetics in college and had to calculate the percentage of white and black on Holstein cows.

I had a very pretty red and white comet that turned all white and a white koi with a few black spots that is getting more black spots over time. When I see a grayish spot on the koi I know it will eventually turn black.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
30,922
Messages
510,007
Members
13,130
Latest member
Miker

Latest Threads

Top