Tropical bog plants in an aquaponics system for the winter

Joined
Jul 27, 2021
Messages
54
Reaction score
102
Country
United States
I have had a couple of aquaponics systems set up in my classroom for a couple of years. I typically grow some herbs, romaine and kale. The romaine and kale are mostly used to feed the tortoise which lives in the classroom for the winter. The tamasaba goldfish are supplied by Beni Hanna Nishikigoi. This summer I had planted a dwarf canna in my bog filter and decided to try to over winter a few stems in the aquaponics. One has already flowered and another is about to.
IMG_2535.jpeg
IMG_2540.jpeg
IMG_2543.jpeg
IMG_2528.jpeg
 
Joined
Oct 1, 2023
Messages
192
Reaction score
105
Location
Northern Utah
Country
United States
Okay, that's awesome! Are the 1/4 inch lines going to the plants powered by your bubbler or some other kind of pump? What are the black plastic squares? Are you adding hydroponic ferts to the water? Do your fish survive off of algae or are you feeding them through some of the empty holes in the lid? It looks like the tank is completely covered by what I assume is styrofoam (except those two holes) - does that cause heat issues or do you just not have a heater in there?

Can't wait to hear more about it.
 
Joined
Jul 27, 2021
Messages
54
Reaction score
102
Country
United States
Okay, that's awesome! Are the 1/4 inch lines going to the plants powered by your bubbler or some other kind of pump? What are the black plastic squares? Are you adding hydroponic ferts to the water? Do your fish survive off of algae or are you feeding them through some of the empty holes in the lid? It looks like the tank is completely covered by what I assume is styrofoam (except those two holes) - does that cause heat issues or do you just not have a heater in there?

Can't wait to hear more about it.
I have two separate systems which are pretty much the same except for the size of the fish and the color of the light View attachment 161145View attachment 161144
Each has two canister filters with the smaller one running to the plants and the bigger on just filtering. The fish are fed a lot. They are tamasaba goldfish from Beni Hanna Nishikigoi. Mat gives me all his babies to grow out over the winter. He comes in a couple of times a year to remove the less ideal fish. This is the first year he has given me year olds to continue growing. I have his top 20 and he will come in February to reduce that to 10. He would like me to get them to softball size by June. The black squares in the previous post are the mounts for the feeder.
IMG_2560.JPG

Sometimes I add dried kelp, epsom salt and cleated iron to the water for the plants. I haven't done that this yet but I need to because my kale is a little yellow.

IMG_2561.JPG

The tops are cut from a sheet HDPE. No heater for the water. One LED grow light was purchased by our PTO and the other was donated by the supplier. The irrigation system is RO tubing and fittings with a bypass for when I need to do maintance.
IMG_2562.JPG
IMG_2563.JPG

I am aerating with a 12v bubbler hooked up to a battery that is connected to a battery charger/maintainer. I had a incident a few years back where there was a power outage on a weekend and then snow days on Monday and Tuesday. The power up after the power outage tripped the GFCIs and the subsequent days of no filtration or aeration resulted in a lot of dead fish.
IMG_2565.JPG

The plants are in 4 in net pot that sit in 4 in pvc that are screened on the other end so fish do get to the roots.
IMG_2566.JPG

I have gone through many different configurations but have settle on this for now. Originally the plants were separate from the tank with grow tents and so on but it was too much. Also, I used to use tilapia and I got some push back from the kids when I started netting them and filleting them. This more simple all in one "desktop" system is not only more manageable but also more visually appealing than what I had before. For example, this canna is really doing well.
IMG_2564.JPG

Please fire away if you have more questions. I wish the kids would ask more questions but they don't
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2558.JPG
    IMG_2558.JPG
    172.6 KB · Views: 6
  • IMG_2559.JPG
    IMG_2559.JPG
    160.5 KB · Views: 7
  • IMG_2560.JPG
    IMG_2560.JPG
    150.2 KB · Views: 5
Joined
Oct 1, 2023
Messages
192
Reaction score
105
Location
Northern Utah
Country
United States
Wow, that sounds so complex, but fun! I tried to set up some sterilite tubs as grow beds above my 55 gal tank once, with water pumped into them through PVC ti ed. I don't think I ever got the bell siphons to work and the only things I remember successfully growing was spider mites. I haveore understanding and ideas now but my wife tells me I can have a pond OR an aquarium but not both. So a pond it is - easy choice. I'd love to have an aquapobics setup to grow out fish for the pond and keep water lilies and water hyacinths alive.

Your canna is beautiful. How big are your tanks?

The only benihana I know about is the restaurant. Are you growing fish to be served there?
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
30,934
Messages
510,275
Members
13,167
Latest member
Emergency Dentist Katy Te

Latest Threads

Top