Hello all! Sorry for the slow response. I have been out of town.
Thank you for all of the warm welcomes! You all have been amazing in responses and advice. Thank you!
Picture wise, I will see if the owner minds if I post one.
I am 99.9% certain that the previous owners NEVER vacuumed out the bottom of the pond. They told my friend that they never scooped up leaves off the surface of the water, so that's definitly decomposing at the bottom. I have not seen any sort of liner in the pond, so I would assume it's just a dirt/gravel bottom. There is at least an 1-3 inches of muck on the bottom all around, if not more. I haven't ventured out to the middle of the pond yet, because I start sinking the further in I go. Now that could also be due to not enough gravel around to prevent sinking. At least I REALLY hope so. Otherwise, those poor fish have lots of muck below them. We have tried to stir the bottom up as little as possible, because I have read that in the warmer months of the year, any hydrogen sulfide in the muck that is released can be amplified due to the warmer temperature of the water. So we should remove in the spring/fall time. And I am certain there is H2S due to the sulfur smell that comes up from pockets of gas/bubbles when you step in certain areas of the pond. I am looking into possibly using this stuff called Clear Pond Dry Formula to "safely" remove the organic matter, but I haven't found much of any reviews on it, so I have been hesitant to start. Otherwise, I don't know what to do other than shovel it out. There is no real effective way to remove all that is in there without stirring it up the bottom too much.
The pond started clearing up last week after we did a massive removal of over-grown algae (carpet algae, duckweed, etc.). There were at least 4 different types of algae that took over after the previous owners removed the pump and the pond stayed stagnant for a month+ .
I am uncertain of the number of fish in the pond, since we still see new koi we've not seen before. It's been a long process to get it to a good point. I do know there are mainly common goldfish, and a few differeny types of koi.
I hope this has been a decent description of the pond. Thanks again for all the advice!!!