I'll take a stab. Some are still to small to really determine if they will stay or not. I'll also grade them on my opinion of best quality to lowest quality on a scale of one to five with five being the best fish IMO. Again, I'm no judge and I will also give standard fin and Butterfly equal consideration. I'm judging by body confirmation, fin-age, pattern then color.
1- Tancho Shiro Utsuri. #2 but has potential to greatly improve if the black Tancho stays and no other sumi grows in.
2- Hi Bekko, #1 a pure mutt. The only thing this koi has going for it it has good head to body shape for being a larger koi as it grows. the bekko (Black pattern)is extremely weak and off sided and doesn't show any potential Sumi to be grow in later either.
3- Ki Bekko #3 Although this fish has super nice Ki coloration and a lot better bekko the body appears short and stubby (This could be very well due to it moving and the water could be causing some issues with body confirmation. I do worry that the Ki is not stable and it will take 1-2 years to see if the ki will stay or not, If so this could become a very nice looking butterfly as it matures.
4- this one the picture doesn't show some of the coloration clearly so it's kind of hard to determine. It's a #2 at best, it could be a kujaku, or a Ki Matsuba. either way it's not a good example of either, BUT this fish does have nice fins and and the white fins will continue to show off this fish. even though it doesn't have great qualities, I'm willing to bet it becomes one of your more favorite butterflies.
5- Hariwake #5, Nice fish and if the pattern holds this fish will continue to improve. The white is crisp and clean, the red has nice border and even down both sides. On a scale of one to ten for this fish compared to some I have seen. a solid five. It would be better with a secondary pattern but still a nice fish.
6- Yamatonishiki- #2 Poor picture quality makes this one hard to judge but the Hi and the sumi have a lot of weakness and the base white isn't crisp or clean. this will be a interesting koi to watch change as it grows. And it will change a good bit!
7- shiro bekko, Good color but I can't tell much about this fish from the pics.
8- In the middle of the two rows. This is going to be a interesting fish to watch grow up. A Gin Rin Asagi. With a good amount of hi. It could be referred to as Hana Gin Rin Asagi, or Hi Gin Rin Asagi. honestly I still don't know why some are called one and others are call the other. Something i haven't learned yet. This fish I give a 4 with the potential for a lot of improvement. Although not a spectacular fish at this point this fish will get better as it grows and it could be a big favorite as a larger fish.
9- Hi bekko, better coloration than the other one. I can't grade due to the picture quality but there isn't anything special jumping out from the pic provided.
10-Kohaku- #3 nothing real special but it's still small, this fish could lose all it's red, and it could get crisper lines as it grows. Not a bad one but Once you have kept a better quality one for a while you'll probably refer to this one as a mutt.
11- I can't name or grade. To many reflections in the photograph and the movement that was cought at the time of the pic may be distortion this fish greatly. i would like to see a better pic of this one and it's still not a easy one to classify.
12- Looks to be a lemon gin rin hariwake. #2 My bet it changes to a solid white platinum as it grows. I doubt this fish will hold it's ki color for more than a year. Still could turn out to be a really nice fish if it turns solid white. It also has some looks like it might be a Doitsu, (leather skin, German scaled, scaless) To me that would be a plus but some would prefer the scaled one over the doitsu.
13. I'm not sure how to classify this fish. It could actually be classified a couple of different ways. Hariwake, kohaku, orengi? To me one of the better looking fish in your collection. #4 I like the solid orange with the white fins. This fish looks good now and will look good grown as long as his fins stay intact and don't split out they are extra long and if it ever gets in a spawning the fins could get very messed up.
14. Ki Bekko, Little guy isn't it? lol It's got a lot of changes and growing to do. I will say this, It won't look the same in six months. the Ki looks solid at this point on the head, But the sumi on the back has a lot of developing to do.
